The Gapingvoid Email - free insights & inspiration three times a week!
can religion
14 Comments
Oldest
NewestMost Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Todd Jordan
15 years ago
Art exists without religion, but religiousness is an art all its self. 🙂
Susi B
15 years ago
of course not! 🙂
CT Moore
15 years ago
What’s that thing about graven images, again?
JohnO
15 years ago
I think it can, the Protestant reformation did a good job of producing no art, and destroying art in an effort to be rid of idols. So, yes.
Anne Johnson
15 years ago
Great Title !
People have not yet evolved to live without religion. otoh, the more evolved, the more art.
dave mcclure
15 years ago
no, it can’t.
religion needs something to rail against, and vice versa… thus, they both need each other.
(sort of like the way Jon Stewart needs Bill O’Reilly, and vice versa)
Matches Malone
15 years ago
Survey Question? Answer: It depends….
As a commentary on society, well….
You might go from zero to suck pretty quickly if the two didn’t have each other to compete with.
CT Moore
15 years ago
@ mcclure, yeah, you’re right. graven images become a rallying point for the faithful.
@JohnO, even the Protestants needed a crucifix.
Liviu
15 years ago
…but can art exist without religion?
David Terei
15 years ago
As often it does, it comes down to definitions. I would say no or maybe more that the question is invalid, i have a quite broad definition of art and most of religion is included in it.
David Terei
15 years ago
As often it does, it comes down to definitions. I would say no or maybe more that the question is invalid, i have a quite broad definition of art and most of religion is included in it.
borthers
15 years ago
Both man-made concepts originating from human imagination so similar in that regard; less people die for “art” though.
Adam Singer
15 years ago
Yes – one is beautiful (art) and one is a concept that is throw-back to a pre-science civilization (religion). As an artist I really think you do art a disservice with this one Hugh – the two have nothing to do with each other.
Andy O
15 years ago
It may not rely on the picture art of icons, but the hymns and songs that are central to most protestant “liturgy” are art as well. There is a certain art to protestant (and catholic) prayer too, I’d dare say.
There can e no religion without art, because art is how those who seek to experience or express the divine do so.
Art exists without religion, but religiousness is an art all its self. 🙂
of course not! 🙂
What’s that thing about graven images, again?
I think it can, the Protestant reformation did a good job of producing no art, and destroying art in an effort to be rid of idols. So, yes.
Great Title !
People have not yet evolved to live without religion. otoh, the more evolved, the more art.
no, it can’t.
religion needs something to rail against, and vice versa… thus, they both need each other.
(sort of like the way Jon Stewart needs Bill O’Reilly, and vice versa)
Survey Question? Answer: It depends….
As a commentary on society, well….
You might go from zero to suck pretty quickly if the two didn’t have each other to compete with.
@ mcclure, yeah, you’re right. graven images become a rallying point for the faithful.
@JohnO, even the Protestants needed a crucifix.
…but can art exist without religion?
As often it does, it comes down to definitions. I would say no or maybe more that the question is invalid, i have a quite broad definition of art and most of religion is included in it.
As often it does, it comes down to definitions. I would say no or maybe more that the question is invalid, i have a quite broad definition of art and most of religion is included in it.
Both man-made concepts originating from human imagination so similar in that regard; less people die for “art” though.
Yes – one is beautiful (art) and one is a concept that is throw-back to a pre-science civilization (religion). As an artist I really think you do art a disservice with this one Hugh – the two have nothing to do with each other.
It may not rely on the picture art of icons, but the hymns and songs that are central to most protestant “liturgy” are art as well. There is a certain art to protestant (and catholic) prayer too, I’d dare say.
There can e no religion without art, because art is how those who seek to experience or express the divine do so.