Creativity Comes After The Fact

The cartoon above came to me after a Twitter exchange I had with my good friend, the fellow cartoonist-writer-creativity-guru-ninja-whatever, Austin Kleon:

Hugh: If all your songs are songs about writing songs, don’t expect anyone to listen to them.

Austin: The problem with writing about creativity is that it’s often more lucrative than actually being creative.

Hugh: I know. If I had to write about creativity day-in-day-out, I’d kill myself :D

Austin: God, I can’t wait to start making some actual stupid art again.

Ha!

Both Austin and I have both written books on creativity. Mine did really well so far; I expect Austin’s, when it comes out next month, to become a massive bestseller, if I’m still going to carry on believing that there’s any justice in the world.

i.e. I know my stuff, at least on a good day, and Austin DEFINITELY does.

Yet somehow both he and I still feel as clueless as anyone else, even if we do get paid to write books about on the subject. Why? Because, actually:

Creativity comes after the fact.

Kids come up to me and ask me all the time…

Kid: How do I get a “creative” career-thing going like yours?

Hugh: Make something. Grab a piece of paper and a pen or whatever and get cracking…

Kid: What if it isn’t any good?

Hugh: Then you’re screwed.

Kid: Ok, what if it’s pretty good, but it’s still going to take me another twenty or thirty years before the world understands it?

Hugh: Then you’re slightly less screwed.

At that point, they’re already sick of asking me any more questions and so they move on, unhappy. Oh well…

The thing is, people think there’s some set of ideal conditions out there, floating independently in space, that somehow have be met, some magic fairy boxes that need to be ticked off, before you can go and “be creative”, whatever that means.

“I’ve got to quit my job, leave my wife, move to India and become an opium addict yada yada yada…” “I’ve got to drop out of college, move to New York and carry on a forbidden and tumultuous lesbian affair with a Japanese novelist twice my age  yada yada yada…”

Actually, no. The way to be creative is to make stuff. You wake up in the morning, have some breakfast, hit the work bench and get on it with it.

Or not. Maybe you’d rather just hang out, light a joint and watch Star Trek reruns. Your call.

You can’t plan for creativity. You can only plan to do the work.

Whether it ends up being “creative” or not, is decided later. Long after you’ve finished the thing and moved on to something else.

That’s what I mean by it coming “after the fact.”

And so there we are.

Comments

  1. That’s a tough and very personal question..Am I creative, what can I create and can I sustain that on a daily basis?

    At my agency, some are great at copy and can ideate but fail miserably when asked to come up with ideas to launch a new brand. And, it’s tough to understand whether it takes talent or grooming or just exposure!

    I guess it’s a lot about knocking and listening.. when it sounds right you will know. Until then keep knocking.

  2. It seems like everyone I knew in high school moved to Thailand after college for a year, or “took time off” after high school instead of getting right into it. I respect these choices, but I have to wonder if I wasn’t able to flex more creative muscle in the context of diving straight into school and work, and having to find creative solutions to actual problems…instead of waiting around for inspiration.

    Eventually it led to the kind of job that people ask the same kind of questions about. How did you get there, what did it take, etc.

    It happened only after I went to work for a while, and that part you just can’t skip.

    • Ian,

      Yeah, I know that choice you faced.

      I went straight into the workforce… to be honest, I was sick of hanging around so I was glad to do it.

      Two decades later, I’m kinda wishing I spent more time in Thailand or whatever… but I don;t think that would’ve helped me in the end.

      I think it’s when you use “travel” as a crutch, well, that has the same drawbacks as when you use anything as a crutch.

      • Because of the choices I made, I’m able to see the world *because* of the work I do now, not at the expense of it.

        Five years ago, I would have never thought someone would value my work enough to send me around the country, let alone abroad. But I have the best of both worlds, and it’s because of diving right in.

        It’s just one proof point that I made the right choice…for me. I can’t speak for anyone else.

  3. Isn’t it better to spend some years behind the desk and then take some time off (no matter how that tough that is) for Thailand. By know, you will know both the sides and be more open to experiences.

    After school, it can be fun but I am sure how will come home with you.

  4. love both of the exchanges you posted. think at the end of the day, showing up and doing the work is all you can do. can’t stress about if it is good, worth while and or any of those things. all you can do is show up and do it. there is actually no way to really tell someone how to be creative. we all are. what we need to learn is how to get out of our own way and let it out whichever way it wants to come out.

    nothing more. nothing less. yet sometimes the hardest thing to do.

  5. > Kid: What if it isn’t any good?
    > Hugh: Then you’re screwed.

    Noooo !
    Hugh, the rest of the article is great(as is most of your stuff), but I really believe the best answer to this question is “if it’s not good, do it again, work more. It’ll get better.”

    David W. Galenson explained in his book “Old Masters and Young Geniuses” that geniuses are not always those who produce great work when then start. About half of them produce crap, and get better later.

    The trait of great artists is that they never give up.

    • Brandon T. says:

      Well, yes, encouragement is good. If Aretha had stopped before signing with Atlantic, think of how boring R&B would be. But, at the risk of sounding like a curmudgeon, there are far too many people out there who think that because they have a computer and access to the internet, that makes them creative. Really, though, someone should have told them, honestly, that their work was terrible, and they should pursue another line. This is where a mentor or teacher comes in and can separate the wheat from the chaff…

  6. Beyond just waking up and making stuff, it feels like there’s a road one has to walk, from which creativity comes.

    Requires either some serious dissatisfaction with the way things are; or desperate search for tonic to drown a wound. What would a perfectly satisfied, well-adjusted creative-type add to the world? “Here’s a picture of why I’m totally on-board with what you guys came up with”!

    So, you can’t just move to India and have it happen. You have to toil first, and that balance of toiling now for better stuff later is hard.

    (And just whining isn’t an exit plan…)

  7. Sheila Foley says:

    This is all very interesting. A couple of things I’d like to add to the discussion: One is the ability to learn from mistakes. Creatives aren’t afraid to be wrong – their “mistakes” aren’t throw-aways. They’re part of the process. Creative types aren’t easily discouraged. They take risks and therefore make lots of mistakes. They’re bound to hit on something good eventually and a confident creative knows that. Secondly, there’s experience. The broader range of experience one has, the easier it becomes to connect one thing to another. What may seem totally unrelated to the average observer, is so obviously connected in the mind/eye/heart of the creative person. And the older you get, the easier it is to recognize that fact.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Hugh MacLeod: The way to be crea­tive is to make stuff. You wake up in the mor­ning, have some break­fast, hit the work bench and get on it with it. [...] [...]

  2. [...] 3) Creativity Comes After The Fact – gapingvoid has become one of my favorite things to read in the morning. I even have one of his cartoons as the lock screen picture on my phone. This particular one really made me think… and then get to work. [...]

  3. Angike.com says:

    [...] what Hugh MacLeod mean by it coming “after [...]

Speak Your Mind

*

Comment through Twitter

Are you ready to work with us?

Get More Info

Testimonials

Hugh MacLeod is a genius.  Genius.

Seth Godin
Best Selling Author

His work acknowledges the absurdity of workaday life, while also encouraging employees to respond with passion, creativity, and non-conformity...   MacLeod’s work is undeniably an improvement over the office schlock of yore. At its best, it’s more honest, and more cognizant of the entrepreneurial psyche, while still retaining some idealism.

The New Republic
Lydia Depillis

Last year my State of the College address was 76 slides loaded with data. This year it was 14 cartoons that were substantially more memorable.

Len Schlesinger
Former President, Babson College

"There are only two daily newsletters that I look forward to opening and reading every time they show up to my inbox: Seth Godin's and gapingvoid."

Tony Hsieh
CEO, Zappos

In moments of indecision I glance at the wall [to Hugh's work] for guidance.

Brian Clark
@copyblogger
 
  • Seth Godin
  • The New Republic
  • Len Schlesinger
  • Tony Hsieh
  • Brian Clark
prevnext