March 6, 2005

metascoble

Robert Sco­ble (Man, I haven’t writ­ten about him in days– I must be losing my touch) res­ponds to my recent “Meta­blog­ging is Dead” post.

I don’t disa­gree with Hugh. I’m trying to catch the Hugh­train. Meta­blog­ging is defi­ni­tely out of style, as Hugh says. I’ll try to only do that kind of stuff over on our book blog. Of course, does tal­king about this here mean a new kind of meta­blog­ging? Not­me­ta­blog­ging? Hmmm.

I think tal­king about blogs is fine, I think fin­ding them inte­res­ting is fine, but you have to remem­ber the sec­ret of French cui­sine: Never let the sauce overwhelm the dish. What’s true with coo­king is also true with blog­ging. And yes, Robert grasps this about as well anyone I can think of.

"Hugh's Daily Cartoon" Newsletter. A new cartoon sent out every weekday morning to your inbox [RSS version here.]. A wee chuckle to start your day off right etc.

5 Responses to “metascoble”

  1. Beck says:

    A lot of the pro­blem is that (most) blog­gers enjoy thin­king about/writing about/reading about meta­blog­ging. In the pro­cess, they com­ple­tely for­get that most of their rea­ders don’t have blogs of their own, and the sub­ject comes off as inside-baseball.

  2. hugh macleod says:

    Good point, Beck. Seriously, I keep thin­king the only who read my blog are the peo­ple who link to me or leave com­ments. A dozen rea­ders or so a day, wha­te­ver.
    In fact, it’s a bit more than that.

  3. Troy Worman says:

    I hate to disa­gree with you, Hugh, because you are so fuc­king inti­mi­da­ting, so I won’t.

  4. Niall Cook says:

    Hugh, you have finally lost it.
    First you tell us that “mar­kets are con­ver­sa­tions”, and there is clearly a mar­ket for blog­ging sprin­ging up around us.
    Now you’re saying that peo­ple who want to have con­ver­sa­tions within this new mar­ket are over.
    Surely, ergo mar­kets are not con­ver­sa­tions.
    Huh?

  5. peter says:

    Don’t be inti­mi­da­ted by Hugh. He does not appre­ciate cri­ti­cism but I feel he has a good heart. Some­ti­mes he for­gets rule 26.
    Wins­ton Churchill: “Hop­kins you were rude to ME!
    Ser­vant “Yes Sir but you were rude to me first“
    Wins­ton Churchill: “But I am a great man”